Netflix’s “The Baby-Sitters Club”: A Beacon of Inclusion in Modern Television

July 22, 2020 / Kai Shappley/ by Netflix

Netflix’s fresh take on the beloved 1990s series "The Baby-Sitters Club" has been met with enthusiastic approval for its heartfelt inclusivity and diverse casting choices. This reimagined series is not only a nostalgic trip for those who grew up with the original books but also introduces a modern twist that resonates with today's younger audience. The show features the familiar group of friends: Kristy Thomas (Sophie Grace), Mary-Anne Spier (Malia Baker), Claudia Kishi (Momona Tamada), Stacey McGill (Shay Rudolph), and Dawn Schafer (Xochitl Gomez). Their adventures delve into contemporary issues like single-parent families, chronic illness, and cultural identity, reflecting the complexities of growing up in America today.

A particularly poignant narrative choice in the series is its representation of Japanese-American culture, exemplified in a subtle yet significant scene where the audience sees a pile of shoes outside Claudia's home—a common practice in many Asian households. This detail, though small, was championed by executive producer Naia Cucukov, who expressed how this inclusion moved her to tears, highlighting the emotional impact of seeing one's culture authentically portrayed on screen.

However, it's the episode titled “Mary-Anne Saves the Day” that has notably captured the hearts of viewers, especially within the LGBTQ+ community. This episode is lauded for its sensitive and respectful inclusion of a young transgender character named Bailey, portrayed by the talented Kai Shappley, a ten-year-old transgender actor. The narrative follows Mary-Anne as she cares for Bailey, who falls ill and requires a visit to the hospital. This storyline not only showcases the everyday realities of transgender individuals but also emphasizes the importance of compassionate and informed care, free from prejudice.

Rachel Shukert, the series showrunner, expressed her intent to weave inclusivity into the fabric of the show right from the start. According to Shukert, while the series has always embodied themes of inclusivity, adapting a specific book chapter to include Bailey’s story was a deliberate decision to ensure that no viewer felt overlooked or excluded. The modifications made to the original plot were minimal, yet they brought an immense depth to the episode, particularly in how it addressed the necessity of respectful and appropriate medical care for transgender youth, ensuring that Bailey was neither misgendered nor marginalized during her medical treatment.

These thoughtful elements have not only enriched the narrative but have also set a standard for what inclusive storytelling can look like in children's television. As audiences enjoy the adventures of The Baby-Sitters Club, they are also presented with an image of a society that embraces diversity in all its forms—be it race, culture, or gender identity.

Further Insights from Kai Shappley

Below, you can watch an interview with Kai Shappley, where she discusses her role as Bailey and the impact of seeing transgender narratives brought to life in such a positive and affirming way.

The inclusion of such narratives in mainstream media like “The Baby-Sitters Club” is a commendable step toward broader societal acceptance and understanding, making it clear that everyone, regardless of background or identity, deserves to see themselves represented and respected in the stories we tell.

Read More Here >